Creamy Mac and Cheese

30min 4 servings
  • 300 g Macaroni pasta2.5 dl cream
    4 dl milk (whole)
    1 tbsp. wholegrain mustard
    2 tbsp. corn starch
    250 g Castello® Mature Cheddar
    Salt and pepper
    0.5 tsp. nutmeg
Creamy Mac and Cheese


Cook the macaroni pasta according to the packet instructions in a large pan of boiling salted water until al dente. In a saucepan add milk and cream and bring to a boil. Season with whole grain mustard, freshly ground pepper and salt. Grate Castello® Mature Cheddar and mix with corn starch. Turn the hob down to a medium heat and stir in grated mature cheddar with the corn-starch, ensuring that you are continually stirring the mixture until the cheese has melted and the sauce is smooth. Drain the macaroni and add to the cheese sauce. Carefully stir for 3-4 minutes until the macaroni is covered with sauce. Season with nutmeg and serve straight away.




This timeless classic is the epitome of feel-good food and will have you hooked after a single bite. Draped in soft notes of citrus and roasted nuts, our Castello® Mature Cheddar takes the lead in our Creamy Mac and Cheese recipe. A great blend of creamy and succulent notes, this Cheddar sets the tone and makes you want to come back for more.

Simple in nature, complex in taste, this Creamy Mac and Cheese is the perfect companion at potlucks or luncheons with friends and family. Experience a seemingly never-ending evolution of flavour from the Cheddar, enhanced by smooth cream and rich whole milk. Let this one be your go-to option when cravings for comfort food has you longing for macaroni and cheese. Follow our recipe on how to make Creamy Mac and Cheese, and watch friends and family fall in love.

Traditional cheese sauce is not meant for longer cooking, and risk clotting and separating after prolonged exposure to heat. In order to prevent the sauce from curdling, and to ensure that you get that silky-smooth texture of the cream in your crockpot, evaporated milk gives the best results. For taste and depth, depending on what you prefer, our Castello® Mature Cheddar and Castello® Aged Havarti act as high points in any macaroni and cheese, either on their own or together. The thick and crumbly texture from having been aged easily melts and mixes and promotes that characteristic and universally loved macaroni and cheese flavour, with a satisfyingly sharp finish.

Show all recipes