Steak burger with mushrooms

Total 30 mins

The ideal burger is gloriously juicy, mouthwateringly cheesy, and unapologetically messy, and this one ticks every box. Succulent steak pairs with mushrooms, tender entrecôte, melting Castello® Mature Cheddar, and brown-ale-cooked caramelised onions, all piled in a soft bun for a satisfying stack of pure enjoyment. And of course, with its irresistible flavours and countless layers, it is perfectly messy – exactly how it should be.

Steak burger with mushrooms Scan to open online

Ingredients

4 burger buns
oil for grilling
2 portobello mushrooms, sliced
4 120 g steaks, for example, entrecotes
50 g rocket leaves, rinsed
4 tbsp good mayonnaise

Beer-caramelised onions

25 g butter
2 onions, thinly sliced
½ tbsp sugar
100 ml brown ale
salt
ground pepper

To serve

chips or potato wedges
chilli flakes for sprinkling

Preparation

Beer-caramelised onions

Melt butter in a pan over medium heat.

Add sugar and onions, then sauté for about 15 minutes, stirring regularly, until softened.

Pour beer over the onions gradually, letting it boil off completely before adding more. Keep going until the onions are caramelised.

Season to taste with salt and pepper.

Steak burger with mushrooms

Heat a grill pan until it is smoking hot.

Grill the steaks for about 2 minutes on each side.

Top each steak with cheese, season with salt and pepper, then set aside to rest.

Brush the mushrooms with oil, then grill them.

Split the buns and warm or toast them.

Spread mayonnaise over the cut sides, then layer with rocket, steak, mushrooms, and onions. Serve with chips or potato wedges.

Tips & Tricks

Choose entrecôte steaks that are similar in size and thickness so they cook at the same rate. This prevents one steak from becoming more done than the others. A thickness of around 2-2½ cm works well for quick grilling.

Tips & Tricks

Take the entrecôte out of the fridge 20-30 minutes before cooking so it can reach room temperature. This helps it cook more evenly from edge to centre and makes it easier to achieve a proper sear without overcooking the inside.

Tips & Tricks

If possible, cook the entrecôte on an outdoor grill instead of a grill pan. The higher heat, open flame, and natural smoke create a stronger sear, defined grill marks, and a subtle smoky note that suits a steak burger perfectly. Keep an eye on the heat, as barbecues can run hotter than expected.

Tips & Tricks

When preparing beer-caramelised onions, pour in the brown ale a little at a time, waiting until it has fully boiled off before adding more. This gradual reduction deepens the flavour and keeps the onions soft and caramelised rather than watery.

FAQ: Questions about the steak burger with mushrooms

Before you head to the kitchen, read through the answers to the most common questions below, so your steak burger with mushrooms turns out perfectly.

  • What type of steaks should I use for a steak burger with mushrooms?

    Entrecôte is ideal for a steak burger with mushrooms as it comes from the rib area and has fine marbling with small streaks of fat running through the meat. Ribeye is cut from the same section and delivers a similar level of tenderness and richness, making it a good substitute. You can also opt for sirloin; though it contains less fat, it requires a little attention on the grill to avoid overcooking. Choose a steak with visible marbling and a good balance between lean meat and fat. A well-marbled cut will stay juicy and tender, which is exactly what you want in a proper steak burger.

  • What doneness should the steaks be for the burgers?

    For a steak burger with mushrooms, entrecôtes are best cooked medium-rare to medium. At this stage, the centre stays lightly pink and juicy, and the marbling has rendered enough to keep the meat tender and flavourful without drying out. Aim for an internal temperature of 52-55°C for medium-rare, or up to 58-60°C if you prefer it slightly more done. As a guide, cook steaks that are 2-2½ cm thick for about 2 minutes per side on a very hot grill pan, adjusting the time slightly depending on thickness. Let the steaks rest for a few minutes before assembling the burgers so the juices can settle back into the meat.

  • What cheese works best for a steak burger with mushrooms?

    A mature Cheddar works particularly well for a steak burger with mushrooms. It melts beautifully and delivers a buttery, nutty flavour that pairs perfectly with entrecôte and earthy mushrooms. Castello® Mature Cheddar is the perfect option, but as an alternative, you can choose an extra mature Cheddar for a sharper flavour, or a younger Cheddar for a softer, creamier melt.

  • Can I make a steak burger with mushrooms in advance?

    No, it is not ideal to make the entire steak burger with mushrooms in advance. Entrecôte is at its juiciest when just grilled and rested, as reheating can affect its texture and tenderness, therefore the steak and the mushrooms are best cooked right before assembling the burgers. However, you can still get ahead by preparing the beer-caramelised onions 1-2 days earlier and storing them in the fridge; simply warm them slowly just before serving.

  • How do I store a leftover steak burger with mushrooms?

    If you have leftovers, store the components in airtight containers in the fridge for up to 2 days. Keep the steak, onions, mushrooms, and buns separate where possible to preserve their texture. Reheat the steak gently over low heat to avoid drying it out, and warm the onions and mushrooms separately before assembling again. While reheated steak will not be quite as tender as freshly cooked steak, careful reheating helps retain as much juiciness as possible.

Cheddar steak burger with caramelised onions and Portobello mushrooms

Ideas and Inspiration

Treat yourself to the ultimate steak burger with portobello mushrooms

Indulge in the ultimate steak burger with portobello mushrooms, a spectacular combination of seared entrecôte, melted Castello® Mature Cheddar, sweet onions, and peppery rocket. Every element is carefully chosen to create a burger that is lavish, rich, and immensely rewarding.

What makes it truly exceptional is the intense umami from the grilled portobello mushrooms, which deliver deep, earthy savouriness and a meaty bite. And as the Cheddar cheese melts over the hot steak, it reveals buttery depth, gentle nuttiness, and a delicate tang that follows you from the first bite through to the final mouthful.

If this burger leaves you wanting more, continue the indulgence with a delectable steak salad, creamy pulled pork mac and cheese, or crisp chilli cheese bites.

Tender and juicy entrecôte steak grilled to perfection

Upgrade your usual burger night by replacing the classic burger patty with an entrecôte steak. The moment it lands in the pan, an immediate, promising sizzle fills the kitchen. As the fine streaks of fat render, they baste the meat from within, keeping the steak juicy and intensifying its flavour, while the edges develop a crisp, caramelised crust. The aroma of seared beef lingers in the air, while the centre stays gloriously pink, tender, and juicy beneath the caramelised crust.

Experience the surprising sensation of beer-caramelised onions

This burger would not be complete without its beer-caramelised onions. Cooked gently in butter, the onions soften and become translucent, releasing their natural sugars. The extra touch of brown sugar enhances that sweetness, encouraging a deep golden hue, while the brown ale simmers and reduces into a rich glaze – this ale contributes subtle malted warmth and a hint of bitterness, keeping the sweetness in check and giving the onions a deeper savouriness.

Enjoy this delectable gourmet burger with tasty sides

Even a magnificent steak burger with mushrooms like this tastes better with the right companions. Go for thick-cut chips or potato wedges, golden on the outside and fluffy within. If you like it a tad bit spicy, try chilli chips, or opt for sweet potato chips that work beautifully alongside the savoury burger. For extra flavour, toss the chips with rosemary and salt, or finish them with grated Parmesan.

When it comes to dipping, mayonnaise and ketchup are often the go-to options. But there is plenty of room to experiment with truffle, garlic, and blue cheese. Truffle mayonnaise pairs beautifully with the earthy Portobello mushrooms, while garlic aioli offers a creamy and bold option with a pungent punch of fresh garlic. A blue cheese dip is another strong contender, adding tang and richness that feels right at home next to a steak.

Level up your burger with extra add-ons

A steak burger with mushrooms already brings plenty of richness, but a few well-chosen extras can take it even further.

One of the best ways to build even more flavour is to add bacon. Crisp and smoky, it brings texture and saltiness that deepen the savoury notes of the steak and mushrooms.

Include vibrant vegetables to bring freshness into every bite – gherkins and pickled red onions provide sharp acidity and crisp texture, whereas ripe tomato slices introduce juiciness and natural sweetness, offering a bright counterpoint to the burger’s deep savoury notes. If you favour a little spice, sliced jalapeños offer a slow-building heat.

You can also enrich the steak itself by basting the entrecôte with butter, crushed garlic, and thyme or rosemary as it cooks. Spoon the foaming butter over the meat so it absorbs the herbal aroma, though make sure to keep an eye on the heat so the steak stays tender and juicy.